Recrafted Shoes

I have a couple of pairs of Allen Edmonds shoes. They’re made in the USA, and quite a “prestige” brand – I bought one pair for my wedding, and before that a simple black pair for work and dress occasions. After I knew what size and width I take, I bought another couple Ā of used pairs on eBay for less than $50 each,Ā becauseĀ I knew they would fit, be comfortable, and be high quality.

One of the reasons I splurged on these shoes isĀ becauseĀ I like the idea of buying something high quality, that will last a long time, and that can be repaired and refurbished rather than thrown away. As well the usual local shoe repairers, Allen Edmonds provide their own recrafting service, where you can send your shoes (for free) to their facility, whereĀ dependingĀ on the level of service you select you can get new heels, new soles, just a deep polish, or a full refurbishment. Then they ship them back to you, no shipping fee.

My black shoes were being worn regularly to work, and the leather sole wore through one day. So, I brought them into the store one lunchtime, and dropped them off for a full recrafting (not the super one with all the extras, but the next one down).

After a couple of weeks, I received an email telling me my shoes were ready, andĀ includingĀ a couple of photos:


Shortly after that, my recrafted shoes arrived at my house. They looked really good, with a deep shine, new laces, new heel and spotless new sole.

Since then, I’ve worn them a couple of times, and I’ve got them on now. The problem is, they seem a little tight now.

The weird thing is with these fancy shoes is how comfortable they have been. I know that sounds silly. I used to have a pair of dress shoes in the UK that literally made my feet bleed. By the time I’d broken them in so they were comfortable, the soles had worn out. I took them to the cobbler in Tooting, who replaced the soles, and they lasted me for a while after that, but I thought that was how it worked. You got some stiff shoes and wore them in.

That’s a another reason the Allen Edmonds (and other quality shoes I guess) were a revelation. They were comfortable out of the box, fitting well, with no pinching or rubbing. You wouldn’t jog in them, and they’re not as soft and slouchy as my slippers, obviously. But great for the office and dressy events.

So now my shoes that were comfortable from the start, and had been worn in so they were even more fitted to my feet, squeeze across the top of my foot and pinch my big toe causing me to limp, I’m a little disappointed. I emailed Allen Edmonds, and they responded quickly with the offer of taking them back and checking them. Good service, but I’ll call them first and discuss it before sending them off for another trip. I’ll keep you posted.

I have another pair currently being recrafted – one of the eBay pairs. They were pretty well worn before I got them, and I’ve worn them a lot since, so sending them off for the full fancy treatment is good value to me. We’ll see how they get on.

I hope they come out well. If this service doesn’t work out, it means I’ve spent a load on shoes because they can be recrafted, only to find that they have to be recrafted very often, and they don’t come back as the sameĀ comfortableĀ shoes I bought. A poor value proposition.

I’m hopeful though. The email response to my query makes me think they actually care about service.